Discussion
Discussion section outline
To write: Restate the aim or question of the study in one sentence.
1. Principal findings
Tip: Open with the main result, in a sentence, without repeating the Results section.
To write: State the principal finding in one sentence: “We found that [result], [with its size or direction].”
2. Comparison with earlier research
Tip: Set your results against earlier studies and spend the most time where they differ. Explain differences by sample, method, measure or setting.
To write: For each relevant earlier study: “[Author, year] found [result]; ours is [consistent with / larger than / different from] it.”
To write: Where your results differ from earlier work, say why: a different sample, method, measure or setting.
3. Interpretation
Tip: Offer possible explanations and a rival one. Where the design cannot show cause, write “suggests” or “is consistent with”.
To write: Offer an explanation: “One possible explanation is [mechanism]. An alternative is [rival explanation], which our design [can / cannot] rule out.”
4. Implications
Tip: Say what the findings mean for practice, policy and theory, and go no further than the evidence does.
For practice or policy
To write: Say what practitioners or policymakers might do differently, and how far the evidence supports it.
For theory
To write: Say how the findings support, qualify or challenge a theory or earlier model.
5. Limitations
Tip: Name the limits of design, sample and measures, and say which way each could bias the result and by how much (STROBE asks for direction and magnitude of bias). Say how far the results apply beyond your sample.
To write: List the main limitations of design, sample and measures, with the likely direction of bias: “Because [feature], [result] may be [over/under]estimated.”
6. Unanswered questions and future research
Tip: Turn the limits and open questions into specific studies someone could run.
To write: Name specific studies the work points to: “Future research should test whether [question], using [design].”
7. Closing message
Tip: End with a message the reader can carry away, and the caveat it needs.
To write: Close with the take-home message and its main caveat.